By Rebekah Pierce, Farmer and Co-Owner of J&R Pierce Family Farm
As Americans, we love farmland. We love farmland even more than we love baseball, apple pie, and pickup trucks, all quintessential aspects of the American experience in their own right.
Nothing beats those vast, open fields of corn, wheat, and soybeans. Nothing beats the red barns, the languid grazing cattle, the landscape that goes on for miles. We love it all.
We love it so much that we’ve spent decades passing laws to protect it. Beginning in the 1970s, states adopted right-to-farm laws to protect agricultural operations from nuisance complaints as residential development began to sprawl outward from major metropolitan areas into rural communities.
The principle behind these laws was singular and straightforward: if you move next to a working farm, you shouldn’t have the right to shut it down because you don’t like the smell of manure, the sound of machinery, or any of the other less-than-postcard-perfect realities of production agriculture.
Today, all 50 states have some form of right-to-farm law, and although their terms vary considerably, they establish an important principle. Agriculture deserves protection from outside pressures that threaten its ability to operate.
Personally, I think it’s time we expand that conversation.
If we believe so strongly in protecting the right to farm, shouldn’t we be equally concerned with protecting a farmer’s ability to keep farming?
[subscribe with caption button]
Preserving Farmland Doesn’t Always Preserve Farming
There’s a rather significant flaw in how Americans approach farmland preservation: we spend an extraordinary amount of time worrying about what happens to agricultural land, and considerably less time worrying about whether anyone can afford to farm it.
The United States lost nearly 209,000 farms between 2012 and 2022, roughly 10% of the country’s farms in a single decade. And the economics aren’t getting any friendlier. The USDA forecasts that farm production expenses will surpass $492 billion in 2026, a 4.5% increase over 2025.
We’re paying more for equipment, fuel, fertilizer, and other basic costs of doing business, often with little (or no) control over the prices we receive for what we’ve produced.
My husband and I operate a farm in northern New York. We raise sheep and cattle, managing grazing contracts on community solar sites, and we spend a frankly obscene amount of time staring at spreadsheets, trying to figure out how to make the numbers work.
Like most farmers, we don’t have the luxury of raising our prices every time diesel prices begin to inch upward. And while the public might love the sight of our sheep grazing across a vast, open, green pasture, that kind of picturesque landscape doesn’t pay that diesel bill.
In our region, agricultural acreage is often fragmented into smaller parcels, making it difficult to assemble enough contiguous land to support a growing livestock operation. Five acres here, another twenty there. Buying hundreds of acres is financially unrealistic for us, with farm real estate averaging $4,500 an acre, so leasing pasture has always been the only option.
And therein lies the problem. A field can remain undeveloped, agriculturally zoned, and virtually unchanged from our grandparents’ time. But what good is preserving that landscape if the business farming it can no longer afford to survive?
We may have preserved the acreage. But we haven’t necessarily preserved agriculture.
Why Do We Protest When Farmers Adapt?
We’ve received considerable pushback for our decision to flip our business model. Unable to afford enough land of our own, we previously leased pasture from other landowners. In 2026, average pasture rent in the Northeast reached $43 per acre. We graze around 200 acres, a drop in the proverbial bucket for commercial grazing operations. At that rate, it would be $8,600 a year just to access the land, before even accounting for the hay we need to get through the other six months of snowy winter.
And there’s another cost that doesn’t show up squarely on a balance sheet: uncertainty. When you’re renting land, you constantly wonder whether the owner will renew the lease, sell the property, or use it for something else.
With solar grazing, we use sheep to manage vegetation beneath and around solar panels, providing a service to solar operators while we continue to produce agricultural products. The work is the same as it would be without solar: the sheep graze, fertilize the soil, and turn the forage into meat. We manage their movement, monitor pasture conditions, and handle the many other tasks that come with raising livestock.
The land is still being farmed, just in a way that makes better financial sense. And frankly, our sheep couldn’t care less whether there’s a solar panel above their heads.
Agrivoltaics isn’t automatically “better” for every acre, farmer, or ecosystem. But it offers intriguing conservation benefits beyond the economic ones: a 2026 Cornell University study found that low-density sheep grazing on a solar installation increased the abundance of certain beneficial insects by 38% compared with mowing. It can also improve soil fertility, livestock health, and more.
Considering how much time we spend discussing the need to keep farmland in production, you’d think more people would be interested in an arrangement that can accomplish exactly that. Yet I spend an astounding amount of time trying to convince people that this is still agriculture.
Still agriculture, but with a different business model. Still agriculture, but with a better chance of being in business five, ten, or fifteen years from now.
Farmland Preservation Should Protect the Farmer, Too
None of this means I believe every solar project should be approved simply “because.” I believe private property rights should coexist alongside reasonable responsibilities to surrounding communities.
That said, the solution shouldn’t be to assume that every solar project on farmland represents the same agricultural loss. We need to look at how the land will be used, whether agricultural production can continue, and what the project means for the farmers whose livelihoods depend on it. Too often, discussions about farmland preservation happen around farmers rather than with them.
I understand why Americans want to protect farmland. I want to protect it, too. But the future of American agriculture shouldn’t be dictated by nostalgia for its past.
The red barns and rolling pastures we love are part of a working industry, supported by real people who need to make an actual living.
If a farmer can diversify their business into agritourism, or sell value-added products, or adopt new technology, whether that’s a John Deere tractor equipped with the latest GPS or a robotic milking system, why shouldn’t agrivoltaics receive the same thoughtful consideration?
Not every opportunity will make sense. And not every proposed innovation delivers the benefits its proponents promise. But preserving agriculture requires leaving room for farmers to make those decisions for themselves, rather than insisting the industry remain frozen in some idealized version of the American countryside.
Right-to-farm laws were created because we recognized that farming needed protection from the changing world around it. Perhaps it’s time we recognized that farming also needs the freedom to change with that world.
We can’t save agriculture in America by preserving the land while continuing to make it harder and harder for farmers to earn a living from it. The farms we admire aren’t museum exhibits. They’re businesses.
The right to farm must include the right to adapt.
Rebekah Pierce is a farmer, writer, and co-owner of J&R Pierce Family Farm, a livestock operation specializing in solar grazing across northern New York. She’s the author of Agri-Energy, Growing Power: Growing Food (Island Press, 2025), and writes about agriculture, land use, conservation, and the challenges of keeping American farms in business.



The Woolly Pulpit, more like! Love this idea a lot. Have you thought about the legal components of changing right-to-farm laws, state by state? Is there a provision or set of incentives for states to do this that could be included in a federal law, like the Farm Bill?